Antenna choices

Looking to get a BlueBoat, trying to learn what elements are most important to improve first.
$100 to spend - get the mast on the boat, or the panel antenna first?

$200 to spend - mast plus panel, or the yagi (without mast) for $150.

With unlimited budget choices are easy, but want to identify the biggest bang for the buck as I go.

Hi @donaldsfei, welcome to the forum :slight_smile:

The mast is a baseline improvement to every antenna option, with minimal operational limitations (unless you intend to operate under very low bridges/piers), which makes it a great initial upgrade while you learn more about what kinds of operations you’re likely to perform.

Whether the antenna alternatives are valuable depends on how you want to operate and what kind of range would be valuable to that, factoring in that tighter directionality gives longer range at the expense of additional adjustments to track the vehicle during operation (unless you tend to do missions in a straight line away from the antenna), and a cellular modem can dramatically increase range but only if you’re operating near civilisation, and it has an additional ongoing expense of the cellular data plan.

Thanks for the note. I’m OK in doing sort of rectangular patterns or surveys that start/end in a somewhat narrow band. Let’s say my survey rectangle is 100x400ft. When the panel angle coverage is described as 45 degree, is that the interior angle total, or 45 off the perpendicular to the face (90 degree total). (The Yagi I expect is expressed on the same basis).

So if I’m roughly near the midpoint of the short side, is the signal falling off a cliff outside of that angle, or are those uncovered triangles corners still getting decent signal due to proximity (worst directly left and right, 90 degrees off axis, but also closest, at 50 ft). Or am I better off backing off the nearest edge to get the nearside (but losing some of the far edge range.

For LTE, would it be possible to put a cell phone in the hull with wifi hotspot active, and make the blueboat a client (and thus the base station also part of the same network via its connection to the boat?)

The specified angles are total beam widths, which is also shown visually in the usage guide.

Antenna beamwidths are determined using “half power” points - ie the signal at those angles is already half of the maximum, and continues to drop off sharply from there.

That depends on your operating conditions and mission requirements. If you’re ok with periods of no telemetry, and can see visually if something has gone wrong with the vehicle / a hazard is visible (in which case you can turn the antenna to regain connectivity, noting that increases the time to respond to an emergency) then you may be able to benefit from the extra range that comes from being close to an autonomous survey region.

On the other hand, if your intended survey region is already well within the range of your antenna then there’s more value in locating and orienting the antenna such that the full survey stays within its beam, for the peace of mind that you’ll have continual communication with the vehicle without adjustments required.

You may also have local regulations that require continual communication with and control over the boat, in which case your options are more limited.

That should be possible, but then you have a separate device’s powering, thermals, and software to manage, and lose some of the range benefits of a dedicated cellular modem by not having an external antenna for it.

Not certain what you mean by this - the BaseStation connects via wifi, not cellular. If both are connected simultaneously to the boat it may be possible to bridge the networks via tunnelling on the onboard Raspberry Pi, but that’s not an inherent feature of connecting to two things - just as a phone being connected to cellular and a wifi router doesn’t automatically provide internet access to everything else connected to that router when it doesn’t have a connection to a modem.

Hi @donaldsfei -
Chiming in to expand on what @EliotBR points out -

Cockpit 1.19 lets you place a base station on the map, and point it at a compass heading. This can help you align your real-world antenna with a predicted angle to cover your signal region. I’ve found the predictions fairly accurate, as long as a line of sight exists and you have decent antenna height on your Base Station.


Enable “show signal on map” - for this survey with max range of ~650m, I’d have to reposition it 4-5 times - that’s really not much trouble when the Blue Boat is doing the rest!

At close range, <50-100m, a directional antenna typically doesn’t need to be pointed as precisely as when at the limits of its achievable range! Ardupilot has a dedicated branch for antenna tracking…

Whether using the USB cellular modem or a phone acting as an internet source (they often use less power and perform better if data tethering via USB connection than WiFi hotspot mode), the BlueOS extension ZeroTier and/or Tailscale (new extension!) can be used to put your system on a virtual network - once you install client software on your computer, you can communicate across the link. Because this link prioritizes the shortest ping, it may switch to using your BaseStation WiFi link, switching from the initial connection over the internet. This can be avoided by using one device without a BaseStation connection as the failsafe (like a phone) and the main control via computer connected to the BaseStation.